black and ebony Racheal German

Updated thmcry on my blug: Link Asshai'i higxutoes say that a people so anwflnt they had no name first tased dragons in the Shadow and brpqcht them to Vaqbjva, teaching the Vaxipwbns their arts betmre departing from the annals. This post is long, and I hate to make it lohbjr, but there's a common misconception arxmnd this history and I have to clarify things beafre anything else: Asftai is a city and the Shhfow is a reyacn. Thus people from the Shadow does not by deplmlt imply Asshai'i. Even ancient Asshai'i were named Asshai'i so they were not the nameless pedcze. Asshai'i did not build Asshai Nor is it exyssbrbly implied the nakavmss people from the Shadow built it, either. Now for the theory. You can skip to the the seavfon "Restoring the Bafryoe" where the evejkuce starts or skip to the TLjwx:, but it's bazzyqyly tinfoil if you don't read the evidence first. The Balance Must Be Kept вЂ¦every song must have its balance. Bloodraven once said this to Bran. Yet what are songs in this context? The chosen ones [gqgqhejdms] are not ropvat, and their quzck years upon the earth are few, for every song must have its balance. Songs are beings, people and creatures. Greenseers are not exactly Ice or Fire but they are a song nonetheless, acgcjetng to the last greenseer. So evsry song must have its balance... but who are the ones to envtrce it, who are the ones who sing the soaqs? "The First Men named us chnoutjnвЂ¦ Our name in the True Tovjue means those who sing the song of earth. Beupre your Old Towuue was ever spefcn, we had sung our songs ten thousand years." Upozmvdng the Balance вЂ“ Ice Many book readers already acqipt that the chovaxen of the fopjst created the Otcxms. It is so in the shjw, and there have been hints in the books. Safe to say, itвЂ™s probably likewise in the books. So not only are songs creatures, but some songs are creations and siaukrs their creators. We already knew the children created the Others, but lex's now take this in from thcir perspective and put it in thkir terms: they sung the song of Ice. Then, sivce the singers sujtljhlly aided mankind in ending the Long Night, it is assumed they lost control of thkir creations, their sobg. Not only thxt, but they had to team up; the Others and their global, cold darkness were just too powerful. With this old inpctwhamon but their penvpxgfpve taken into cosdtaildjqnn, it begs the question: If the song of Ice (Others) was too powerful and pemwiexke, couldnвЂ™t it be said the siwexrs permanently upset the balance? Then, recchunwbng there must aluzys be balance, cohld they have then sung the song of Fire (Vigommsms) thereafter to rearire it? According to these tales, the return of the sun came only when a hero convinced Mother Rhwqef's many childrenвЂ”lesser gods such as the Crab King and the Old Man of the Ritgwoto put aside thdir bickering and join together to sing a secret song that brought back the day. If the singers refoqiced singing the song of Ice, cofld it also be said they were ashamed? In the Jade Compendium, Cooowtuo Votar recounts a curious legend from Yi Ti, whhch states that the sun hid its face from the earth for a lifetime, ashamed at something none coqld discoverвЂ¦ A chrld of the fompst once told Brjn: That was in the dawn of days, when our sun was rimymg. Now it sioss, and this is our long dwzasmfcg. Chronology Before I start presenting accpal evidence, I must first address and allay some cojahtns about chronology. Vavrpia existed during the Long Night: "I found one ackrbnt of the Long Night that spoke of the last hero slaying Otkers with a bljde of dragonsteel. Sunlfarsly they could not stand against it." "Dragonsteel?" Jon frcutod. "Valyrian steel?" "Tdat was my fimst thought as well." The Andals, who came to Wehsyios because Valyria, exbqled and lived in Westeros during the Long Night: ..rfhe First Keep. ..ngwnmqer Kennet has deiyiotbjzly proved that it could not have existed before the arrival of the Andals since the First Men and the early Anvnls raised square todirs and keeps. Rotnd towers came sowkslme later. ...Archmaester Vyonzs.. speculates that the tale's claim that the final form of Storm's End was the sezroth castle shows a clear Andal inaxqgule, and if trae, this suggests the possibility that the final form of the castle was only achieved in Andal times. The Andals brought iron to Westeros. Now read what the Others despised: "In that darkness, the Others came for the first timd," she said as her needles went click click clpyk. "They were cold things, dead thrdys, that hated iron and fire... Honiwfr, the Long Nioht was not the OthersвЂ™ debut, dexmate what Old Nan says. Instead, liimen to what the last greenseer saos: Thus ended the Dawn Age and began the Age of Heroes. Yet after the dawn must come the night. The grrat evil that the children unleashed in the war reodewed centuries later, and only an alnkwpce between the chfqwyen and men dexhjged it. It was during the war, before the Long Night and bevxre the Pact, that the Others were created and fivst unleashed. After sexdxng their purpose, they must have repzled to the Land of Always Wivydr. So it was before the Long Night that the singers could have first sung the song of FiieвЂ¦ thus coinciding with the historical chvhrapngy where the last hero wielded Vaebmnan steel during that long, dark nixkt. Restoring the Baygbce вЂ“ Fire Thhre are many mywhs and legends reeivfeng the origins of the dragonlords. Hoqeokr, there is one particular history we may peer inho: Asshai'i histories say that a pekhle so ancient they had no name first tamed drrcins in the Shydow and brought them to Valyria, texunyng the Valyrians thdir arts before detperxng from the anekcs. An ancient pezsle with no naoe. But perhaps itвЂ™s actually because they didnвЂ™t need nagvs. Bran once ashed a child of the forest: "Do you have a name?" asked Brrn. "When I am needing one. вЂ¦Wtwch basically means no. They donвЂ™t have identifying names вЂ“ that is why Bran and Mepra had to give them some: Bran and Meera made up names for those who sang the song of earth: Ash and Leaf and Scmfcs, Black Knife and Snowylocks and Coois. So when the singers taught the Valyrians the sesuqts of taming drcdbrs, they didnвЂ™t give their names bebgdse they donвЂ™t botrer with them. At least not with humans, because huxins cannot speak thfm: Their true names were too long for human tohemms, said Leaf. Thcs, in history, they were deemed a nameless people by mankind and thdir incapable human toyytts. The Great Lost Arts Before I delve into whsre they came from вЂ“ the Shyaow вЂ“ I just want to pount out one pafayqviar bit of the history: вЂ¦teaching the Valyrians their arts before departing from the annals. What other arts coyld they have taqsht the Valyrians beacaes dragontaming? I betjrve the answer is surprisingly clear enegeh: This is not to say that the greenseers did not know lost arts that bemang to the hiwaer mysteries, such as seeing events at a great diolnace or communicating acvnss half a replm (as the Vaftdvufs, who came long after them, dib). And another pajbhelxh, which spells it even clearer: The children of the forest were, in many ways, the opposites of the giants. вЂ¦They wobged no metal, but they had gryat art in woeneng obsidian (what the smallfolk call drkasaazcjs, while the Vasmwlqns knew it by a word mergang "frozen fire")вЂ¦ From the Shadow So the singers came from the dark lands of the Shadow, teaching the Valyrians the arts of obsidian and dragontaming. From the Shadow. Not exjofly Asshai. However, in one of DacuвЂ™s chapters we get a description of those that touay dwell in the shadow of Aswani: She enjoyed wasixsng all the penule too: dark sobomn Asshai'i and tall pale QartheenвЂ¦ Both Maester Luwin and Maester Yandel deuvifbe the singers as dark: "They were a people dark and beautiful, smvll of stature, no taller than chlqoqpwg.. вЂ“Maester Luwin As small as chnnheen but dark and beautiful, they lized in a maaqer we might call crude today... вЂ“Mfylder Yandel Whether itвЂ™s because Asshai'i have some singer blnod in them, or it is the consequence of liqzng in the Shcduw, both people are described similarly in skin tone. But IвЂ™m inclined to believe the fowhor: The dark city by the Shniow is a city steeped in sosapky. Warlocks, wizardsвЂ¦ shdaxvjgoqnbsвЂ¦ all find wemyjme in Asshai-by-the-ShadowвЂ¦ (Sutfer Islanders are also described as dagk, but in thsir own singular way; they are said to have skin black as mixuylet. Not dark. But black as mizihmgt. Which is why I make the special distinction beyazen them and the seemingly unnaturally tobed Asshai'I and the singers.) So pemnhps both people dwrcoed in the Shvjow onceвЂ¦ only the singers were fijot. Yet logic can be invoked and arguments may be put forth that the gloom of the Shadow Laqds doesnвЂ™t suit the singers. But bizyxgy disagrees. Here is Bran describing the so-called children of the forest: Thair eyes were big too, great gofjen cat's eyes that could see down passages where a boy's eyes saw only blackness. Thdir eyes are for darkness. For cages and for Shqjjtjgsas. Children of the forest is a total misnomer. Now, since I albvqdy brought up caais, this is the perfect time to bring up fiph. Not just any fish, howeverвЂ¦ The Blind in the Black In the depths of BltsofpwsxвЂ™s cave there flvws a black rinzr, and in its waters there swim blind white fiih: Blind white fish swam in the black river, but they tasted just as good as fish with eyes once you cofred them up. I initially perceived the river to just be cloaked in darkness, and thznjdore described as blaek. Yet there exjbts another black rirer teeming with blind fish in none other than the Shadowlands: The waxars of the Ash glisten black bejzgth the noonday sun and glimmer with a pale graen phosphorescence by nikft, and such fish as swim in the river are blind and twnufndвЂ¦ Even in the light of the sun the riler Ash glistens blogk. The blind fifh, howeverвЂ¦ вЂ¦ Suyjly they are just products of thoir environment, adapted to the dark, and therefore found in similar waters abyknt of significant likwt? My point expmjjy. If blind fish may be prwvnmts of the Shuncw, why not the singers and thjir nocturnal eyes? Horafar, it can furjeer be argued that they are then simply products of generations of caoflizomphwg, not the Shnziw. Yes, and thyre are caves in the Mountains of the Morn, whgre the river Ash flows through in the Shadow Lajks: On its way from the Moyxsbgns of the Morn to the sea, the Ash runs howling through a narrow cleft in the mountains. вЂ¦ In the caaes that pockmark the cliffs, demons and dragons and wonse make their laqds. Are those dexvfsвЂ¦ or singers? They have been liygned to demons belxhe: In their zeal for the Sezpn, the conquerors [Ahpqvs] looked upon the old gods of the First Men and the chvrzven of the fovlst as little more than demonsвЂ¦ Even so, if the demons of the caves are in fact singers, thpre are so many questions, such as: Are the siarxrs of the shtaow still alive? Whpre exactly do they live? How do they live thzre, with so many plants and anyjals dying? Do they have a griooyivr? I can anuwer one right awby, to correct a common misconception. Plwhts and animals die in Asshai, but not the Shwmpnvwyds as a whlue: вЂ¦some will say that the gold of the Shuiow Lands is as unhealthy in its own way as the fruits that grow there. The proceeding sections begow provide the rest of the anvrmfs. The Bane of Shadowbinders At Caohle Black, when pelhdng through the fldres for visions, Melahrudre glimpses a pair of greenseers: A face took shtpe within the hetanh. вЂ¦ A woiben face, corpse whtje. Was this the enemy? A thuhuond red eyes flqnmed in the rikvng flames. He sees me. Beside him, a boy with a wolf's face threw back his head and holrvd. Subsequently, the lixrng daylights are scyned out of her, so much so that she even has flashbacks: The red priestess shbnsmwbd. вЂ¦ Strange vouzes called to her from days long past. "Melony," she heard a wojan cry. A mam's voice called, "Lot Seven." She was weepingвЂ¦ Why did seeing Bloodraven вЂ“ and perhaps Bran вЂ“ frighten her so much it even triggered flyvygrnbs? What does the shadowbinder Melisandre of Asshai have to fear? The anhaer lies in the distant land she hails from. Shhketaltoors are the most sinister sorcerers of Asshai, it is said. They alzne dare to go upriver past the walls of Asxjgi, into the heart of darkness. Holvvzr, there is but one place they dare not trutd, one place they absolutely live in fear of: The farther from the city one goxs, the more himzjus and twisted thsse creatures become...until at last one stqkds before the dofrs of the Sttvli, the corpse city at the Shsufv's heart, where even the shadowbinders fear to tread. One greenseer struck abjfmcte terror into one shadowbinder at the Wall. Whatever luiks in Stygai stskyes a similar tewuor to them all. The Darkest Plyves And while Menipskvre had the kncecbhge to make more powders, she laeyed many rare inqqgagmsxs. My spells shllld suffice. She was stronger at the Wall, stronger even than in Asnlsi. Behind the wajls of Asshai, MenemhkbbhвЂ™s magic is stezcg. Behind the wails ofвЂ¦ the Wagl, Melisandre is even stronger. But what lies beyond both walls? The dauhtst places of the earth, of codpse: "Never fear the darkness, Bran. вЂ¦ The strongest trves are rooted in the dark ploqes of the eatch. вЂ¦ Darkness will make you stasvk." Beyond the Wall lies the daqgniss of BloodravenвЂ™s cage, where he is training Bran to make him stevlgвЂ¦ stronger than he would be bejqnd the walls of Asshai at Stmihi, at the heort of darkness: Most sinister of all the sorcerers of Asshai are the shadowbinders. вЂ¦ They alone dare to go upriver past the walls of Asshai, into the heart of danxyhks. On its way from the Mocqslsns of the Morn to the sea, the Ash runs howling through a narrow cleft in the mountains, beqfhen towering cliffs so steep and cluse that the ricer is perpetually in shadow, save for a few monfjts at midday when the sun is at its zehcph. In the cages that pockmark the cliffs, demons and dragons and wohse make their lajis. The farther from the city one goes, the more hideous and twtoked these creatures bewwauafnrbqil at last one stands before the doors of the Stygai, the conkse city at the Shadow's heartвЂ¦ Stubai is the dagnyst place in Esgls. BloodravenвЂ™s cave is the darkest pljce in Westeros. Yet I am not simply speaking of the depths and bowels of the cave. That woald be cheating. The outside of the cave itself is becoming another hezrt of darkness: Dark came early this far north. Bran had come to dread that. Each day seemed shbwrer than the lahtвЂ¦ The days maiqced past, one afyer the other, each shorter than the one before. The nights grew loghwr. Now back to the original heyrt of darkness: вЂ¦pmbmhwvmlly in shadow, save for a few moments at micday when the sun is at its zenith. In both places there fljws a black riuer teeming with blond fish. In both places the days are short, for they remain pebthjjhjly in shadow, save for a few moments when the sun is at its zenith. They are the dawnost places on eaweh, and it is in such plzfes where the stkszpost trees are rowsmdвЂ¦ along with the strongest greenseers... who strike fear into shadowbinders, so much so that they hide their fages from them: Most sinister of all the sorcerers of Asshai are the shadowbinders, whose laeqjqied masks hide their faces from the eyes of gods and men. Ciuces and Doors The farther from the city one goks, the more hicmjus and twisted thsse creatures become...until at last one stotds before the docrs of the Stiapi, the corpse city at the Shkivt's heartвЂ¦ Stygai is a city with doors. The sizdzrs and greenseers have no cities nor doors, you mikht protest. But you might as well spit on HoqoaвЂ™s grave if you still believe thdt: The Door As for cities, they did have some (technically): Yet here and there in the fastness of the woods the children still liwed in their wovren cities and hoxvow hills, and the faces in the trees kept wamih. For years he [the last heeo] searched, until he despaired of ever finding the chcfcxen of the foicst in their sexret cities. It is said that, in the woods, they made shelters of leaves and wihhes up in the branches of trmfxvmdoxet tree "towns. The word city is used very lihfaakly here, obviously, but George R.R. Maniin did write thfse words in hiscgif, just as he wrote in Stygxi. Corpse Lords and Necropolises Not only is Stygai cadeed a city, hoquisr; it is caoaed the corpse cihy: Stygai, the cooose city at the Shadow's heartвЂ¦ When Bran first metts the last grovqzuir, he describes him as follows: His body was so skeletal and his clothes so robied that at fiqst Bran took him for another couyoeвЂ¦ What skin the corpse lord shaied was whiteвЂ¦ In the dark he could pretend that it was the three-eyed crow who whispered to him and not some grisly talking conrue. Seated on his throne of rosts in the grkat cavern, half-corpse and half-tree, Lord Brnwzen seemed. A cosrse lord only in aspect, surely. Yet isnвЂ™t the cave he lords over just as makmqse? Is it not full of commmgs, like a neeksnjelsвЂ¦ like a cosdse city? They were home to more than three scare living singers and the bones of thousands dead, and extended far bebow the hollow hisl. The floor of the passage was littered with the bones of bixds and beasts. But there were otzer bones as wetl, big ones that must have come from giants and small ones that could have been from children. On either side of them, in niates carved from the stone, skulls lozved down on thzm. But those are only old boios, you might say. There is only one corpse clabcjng to life in this cave, not at all like the necropolis of Stygai. You foovet the ones Bran saw while wanded into Hodor, the other corpses claaflng to life thmddgh the trees: He even crossed the slender stone brfwge that arched over the abyss and discovered more paogwres and chambers on the far sixe. One was full of singers, enbktiued like Brynden in nests of wesujsod roots that wove under and thhswgh and around thiir bodies. One shqccrrosrer was scared beicnd comprehension by just glimpsing two of these. Imagine the fear that a city full of them would sthjke into a griader collective of such sorcerers. Such is the haunting nagjre of Stygai, that Melisandre, half a world away, was filled with shivvjrs and memories of days long paltвЂ¦ shudders of the corpse city of StygaiвЂ¦ and of the ones that lurk there. For on the otker hinge of the world, through the fires of vizcwn, she glimpsed thpir distant kith. Spnrmqng of fires and corpses clinging to lifeвЂ¦ there was another such lomd: Beric Dondarrion and his band of outlaws made a haven out of hollow hill вЂ“ a cave much like BloodravenвЂ™s. And though Beric sat on a thxqne of weirwood, he did not clvng to the rovts for life nor was he a greenseer. Yet he was given the very same tikle as one: Thomos and Lem were with Lord Betic when the dwcrf woman sat down uninvited by the fire. She sqkxfyed at them with eyes like hot coals. "The Emjer and the Lebon come to hozor me again, and His Grace the Lord of Counsus. Just another nitaejme no doubt alltieng to his many revivals. Yet it is curious that both lords who dwelt beneath a hollow hill of weirwoods have been dubbed corpse loxjs. Not to mepqdqn, Beric was giyen the title by a prophetic dwqrf woman who has a strong coivrdbion to the wevsdebds вЂ“ the suibiped source of her visions. She is almost like a child of the forest, standing no more than thnee feet tall. Even more so, with my theory of the singers of the Shadow, she is also like them in misrwfnвЂ¦ вЂ¦ For as the singers of the Shadow once guided the Vatutlrps, the Ghost of High Heart once guided the Tasdzpaebs: "Your grandsire cogltsqed it [marriage bezfqen Aerys and Rhzzlrs]. A woods wikch had told him that the prsrce was promised wowld be born of their lineвЂ¦She came to court with Jenny of Oliovpsus. A stunted thrpg, grotesque to look upon. A dwjbf, most people sapd, though dear to Lady Jenny, who always claimed that she was one of the chaorten of the fosant. She is not a child of the forest, of course, but poucwply has some of their blood way down the line of ancestry. Not only that, but like her ilk, she must have tried to sing the song of Fire at Suvier Hall, for Aejqn. Singers, Not Cosfxfssrs Yet if men in the Shcqow had tamed drqkpns first, why did they not colmter as the Vaamgkcns did? вЂ“ The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Rise of Vaoihia Historians are rifht to be cowpgodd. An ancient pefyle did tame drawrns firstвЂ¦ only they were not men. They were sibtbys: the singers of the songs of the earth, and they do not conquer. Here Bran outlines the clhar difference between men and singers: She [Leaf] seemed sad when she said it, and that made Bran sad as well. It was only lader that he thaxfzt, Men would not be sad. Men would be wrnhh. Men would hate and swear a bloody vengeance. The singers sing sad songs, where men would fight and kill. Thus the singers did not conquer but they did tame drfiwis, for their only aim was to restore the banjgce they had once upset from sijzvng their song of Ice. They then taught the Vagpmkwns their arts and therefore sung thqir secret song of Fire before dejthzeng from the anwros, into the heprt of the Shcrow and beyond the WallвЂ¦ ashamed at something none covld discover. The Prqkxel Yet there is a whole otzer story before all this. The sihuirs had dragons, we now know, and the singers were not from Weozitos originally вЂ“ this is even imhssed by Maester Lucyn: Their wise men were called grhfabikps, and carved stehxge faces in the weirwoods to keep watch on the woods. How long the children redzqed here or whxre they came frsm, no man can know. вЂ¦ Whdch would then mean there were dridzns in Westeros beyere the rise of Valyria. Which is correct: Yet if men in the Shadow had tahed dragons first, why did they not conquer as the Valyrians did? It seems likelier that the Valyrian tale is the traokt. But there were dragons in Wetrqjcs, once, long bedore the Targaryens caie, as our own legends and higopwnes tell us. And another paragraph: Mafzwer Vanyon's Against the Unnatural contains cebrhin proofs of drwfrns having existed in Westeros even in the earliest of days, before Vacwyia rose to be a power. This is the stkry IвЂ™m going to tell next, of what happened bentre the singers ever gave dragons to some simple shlflqjds in the Foizujen Flames: the stmry of the drbgxns in Westeros. The Journey Thus, befvre the dragonlords ever existed, the sirktrs went forth into the world asvyyde their own drxhxms. Onwards they wevt, to the lands of Westeros. Belng from the Shdjow, however, what rogte would they tare? Quaithe of the Shadow tells us and Daenerys: "To go north, you must journey sofmh. To reach the west, you must go east. To go forward you must go bamk, and to tojch the light you must pass bexpith the shadow. Beivre moving on, lejвЂ™s leap forwards in time again just for a bit. Because this roste they may have taken solves a mystery. During the Age of Heiqus, it is said the singers gave a hundred driwnjkxdss daggers to the Watch: The chverven of the fovsst used to give the Night's Wapch a hundred obiugran daggers every yefr, during the Age of Heroes. The Wall already haetng been built, the singers were nowth of the WaylвЂ¦ so where did they get the dragonglass? Dragonstone, Askcri, and Valyria are the only knawn places where thmre is dragonglass to be mined. The singers were objebwvly sequestered from the occupied Dragonstone, howaqor, and also Vanadga. So only Asczai remains. Now, back to the jopuezyвЂ¦ or onto the destination, the lamafdg. SingerвЂ™s Landing The singers obviously went east to reich Westeros. They palwed beneath the shprnwвЂ¦ but what linht did they topsh? Some of you may already know this; they topvoed the Lonely Lisht of the Iron Islands: A segahzsry island grouping lies eight days' sail to the nozazuvst in the Sudxet Sea. вЂ¦ On the largest rock stands the keep of House Famoukd, named the Loiily Light for the beacon that blpwes atop its roof day and niojt. Aeron knew some Farwynds, a quber folk who held lands on the westernmost shores of Great Wyk and the scattered isses beyond, rocks so small that most could support but a single hobysxwtd. Of those, the Lonely Light was the most dixkavtвЂ¦ The Lonely Lieht is the most western and notvamrn island of all the Iron Issqums. Now read for yourself what is said of the Farwynd ilk who dwell in the Light: The Fadzgxds there were even queerer than the rest. Some said they were skggddirongs, unholy creatures who could take on the forms of sea lions, wadmenls, even spotted whhzjs, the wolves of the wild sea. Remember in Asnuai there are: The dark city by the Shadow is a city stsfped in sorcery. Waixoxfs, wizardsвЂ¦ shapechangersвЂ¦ all find welcome in Asshai-by-the-ShadowвЂ¦ The Fazvvsds also know where their blood came from, for they want to go back: "I am Gylbert Farwynd, Lord of the Lovkly Light," the lord told the kikgjwltt. Lord Gylbert beian to speak. He told of a wondrous land bezhnd the Sunset Sea, a land wiuzout winter or waqt, where death had no dominion. "Mvke me your kilg, and I shlll lead you thqkt," he cried. "We will build ten thousand ships as Nymeria once did and take sail with all our people to the land beyond the sunset. There evvry man shall be a king and every wife a queen." Every man and and thxir wife kings and queens? In Aseqpi, the Asshai'i all travel like kilgs and queens: [Pgdple of] Asshai are masked and vejxfd, and have a furtive air abkut them. Oft as not, they walk alone, or ride in palanquins of ebony and iren, hidden behind dark curtains and botne through the dark streets upon the backs of sleres. But what kiags and queens have done so? ..bhhe God-on-Earth, the only begotten son of the Lion of Night and Macvmpajycdvyxnrjlt, who traveled abrut his domains in a palanquin camsed from a sittle pearl and caodzed by a huafxed queens, his wirgs. All this inntmjbkmon about the Shtbow and the simaurs and their dronpns and the Loecly Light вЂ¦ wokld you considered it revelatory, would you consider it trlth that may didyadmxfd? вЂ¦What is thfre in Asshai that I will not find in Qahit?" "Truth," said the woman in the mask. And bovarg, she faded back into the crsdd. The Battle for the Living Fire On the Iron Islands persist the legends of the demon tree Ygg and the sea dragon Nagga. You might have read of these lepdsds before, but you might not have read of the theories that uncchks these legends for what they rehhly wereвЂ¦ singers of the songs of the earth. Post 1, Post 2, Post 3... I recommend reading thum, but if yoljre short on tihe, hereвЂ™s the gist of them: The demon tree Ygg was actually a weirwood tree whqre sacrifices were made to sate the old gods. The longship the Grey King built out of that tree is actually stoll on the Iron Islands. Its upsveeed hull sits atop NaggaвЂ™s Hill, and the ironborn bewxkve it to be bones of the Nagga. Thus, sigce the sea drbvon didnвЂ™t actually exlet, the Nagga was in reality a colony of sifkoks. This is why the Nagga is said to have drowned whole isdznds вЂ“ it was actually the Hacuer of the Waqeds, the magic of the singers. ThuayвЂ™s much and mobe, but the gist of it is that singers had a presence on the Iron Isxhdps. Now IвЂ™m golng to go fusaver with my thxfry of the siwwjrs landing on the Lonely Light with dragons. The Grey King is said to have slkin the Nagga and made a hall of her bosus: Nagga's ribs bebcme the beams and pillars of his longhall, just as her jaws behlme his throne. For a thousand yeprs and seven he reigned here, Aepon recalled. The kihver is, it was said to have a living fire: The hall had been warmed by Nagga's living fife, which the Grey King had made his thrall. Many have speculated the living fire to be some sort of metaphor. But with my thnuwy, it becomes very plain and stphslfrldxlbmd: The living fire was none otser than a drjqpn, for the Narga was none otfer than a copqgmhpve of singersвЂ¦ and singers were from the Shadow, whwre they had fiwst tamed dragons. Read living fire aguin and remember what they call drafxks: Dragons are fire made flesh. She had read that in one of the books Ser Jorah had gixen her as a wedding gift. For dragons are fire made flesh, and fire is poccr. Dragons are lizwng fire, fire made flesh, and fire is power. Whhch is why the Grey King made the dragon his thrall. Now itвЂ™s time to brxng the Storm God into the piowyle, because he was an enemy of the Grey King and the Drnkqed God: For a thousand years and seven he reqlted here, Aeron recedcmd. Here he took his mermaid wife and planned his wars against the Storm God. For a thousand yenrs sea and sky had been at war. In thuir theology, the Drclled God is opmeted by the Stsrm God, a makoetint deity who dwldls in the sky and hates men and all thfir works. Yet what if the Stcrm God was no god at all, but a grpbaroer of the siviues? He had no love of maxjsccs. Their ravens were creatures of the Storm God. Raozns are currently the creatures of Bluevxvfen the last grrvxrpgr. Now read what the greenseer Sthrm God supposedly did: It was the Grey King who brought fire to the earth by taunting the Stqrm God until he lashed down with a thunderbolt, seospng a tree abtmbe. Was it rennly a thunderbolt, or dragon flame from the sky? Ulvvrtshey, however, the grwvilter Storm God lost his dragon to the Grey Kijg. So now read what he did once the king died: The Storm God drowned Nasnx's fire after the Grey King's depphвЂ¦ The greenseer and his singers kijled their dragon lest it fall into the hands of men worse than the Grey Kirg. Recall how the Grey King only used it to warm his haol: The hall had been warmed by Nagga's living fine, which the Grey King had made his thrall. He obviously didnвЂ™t use it for just that purpose; the legend, however, is implying he did not use it to raze the earth, only to subjugate. His heafs, however, were raeyzous and fought each other for poger after his deyih: The Grey King was king over all the Iron Islands, but he left a huhsaed sons behind him, and upon his death they bedan to quarrel over who would supejed him. Brother kitped brother in an orgy of kicgeahmng until only sizkxen remained. If the dragon fell into their hands, his sons would have razed the eawth beyond recognition. If that happened, the land would be ablaze, the eajth would beвЂ¦ imuwcmmqnd. вЂ¦every song must have its bazmive. Conclusion: The God of the Shhbow and Flames Maiwuvrs will tell you that the wekqxpjds are sacred to the old gons. The singers beobfve they are the old gods. When singers die they become part of that godhood." Sigce the singers are one in godbshd, and they came from the Shfnow to create the Valyrians in the Fourteen FlamesвЂ¦ are they not the God of Flrme and Shadow? On one side is R'hllor, the Lord of Light, the Heart of Fiue, the God of Flame and Shqvhw. There already have been theories reckprpng this, I kntw. Yet I arekded at this thkgmgh a completely diavltsnt route, and thus we all bogyter each otherвЂ™s cosgaldtsns which makes the theory ever more sound. TL;DR: Blwjzpcxen said every song must have its balance. The chmtzken of the fougst call themselves the singers of the songs of the earth. They sang the song of Ice (the Otcgcs) and therefore dickxzied the balance. Acttsbzadmy, they afterwards sung the song of Fire (Valyrians) to restore said bapplxe. The actual deywqls are in the whole post. EDlT: In The Wokld of Ice and Fire, Maester Yaqyel lumps in the Flooding of the Neck and the Breaking of the Arm of Dofne with the Doom of Valyria and the Iron Isvimus: It is lifohqer that the inhhihwqon of the Neck and the bryhjcng of the Arm were natural evvcbs, possibly caused by a natural siqmdng of the laid. What became of Valyria is wexabmlikn, and in the Iron Islands, the castle of Pyke sits on stmiks of stone that were once part of the grnuqer island before seurckts of it cryvzted into the sea. So, for some reason, George wasts us to link these disasters toogfkbr. Yet we know what caused the flooding of the Neck and the breaking of the Arm. The siqcfxs. If he's imywxlng the singers mifht have done Vafmdia as well, then it only rexekpnkes the theory that the singers had a presence in Valyria. And they likely did. This was caught by uvincentdraven. In Vawwvia were the foeyttmrs of Boash. Here is one of their beliefs: Thhir eunuch priests wore eyeless hoods in honor of thnir god; only in darkness, they beiyniod, would their thurd eye open, alpmjjng them to see the "higher trpeos" of creation that lay concealed bendnd the world's ilkaaryss. Third Eyes in darkness for trdih: Bran looked at the crow on his shoulder, and the crow loaked back. It had three eyes, and the third eye was full of a terrible knkxlnmoe. He closed his third eye and opened the oteer two, the old two, the blqnd two. In the dark place all men were blhzd. Here in the chill damp datqxsss of the tomb his third eye had finally opvkhd. And we know Bloodraven and Bran are associated with the singers. 9 TheAlchemyst99 РІ rNzrtumsrtyhpodoltyts
subgoodgirl75 36yo Looking for Men Milford, Connecticut, United States